Customer Reviews

Based on 745 reviews
Not Chocolately, Not Nutmegy

I love the consistency and it feels great on my skin. But the scent has more of a powdery smell than a coffee one. And there’s no spice to it at all.

Pearls + Lace Body Wash
Sawkia Patterson

Pearls + Lace Body Wash

Smells so good!

The scent stays on my skin, and sticks to my clothes. I love it.

If you like B&BW cake scents, you’ll love!

If you like B&BW cake scented candles, you’ll love the brown sugar and vanilla body butter. It’s not exactly what I expected but smelled good. It is a VERY strong scent tho. Smells more like a candle than a body product. Very moisturizing. Scent projection and scent trail are insane. People kept telling me I smelled like syrup lol

Smells different

I bought the small 1oz to try out and I loved it. The smell was bright and almost citrusy, perfect for the summer. So I knew I wanted a larger one, but when it arrived it smelled sweeter, hella sweeter like brown sugar or like dessert. I smell like milk tea with boba. I still like it, but definitely different from the batch I got originally. :/

Different formula

When I bought the amber + rum body wash in Fall 2021 it was my favorite body wash I had ever tried. The scent was wonderful, vanilla and toasty. It was thick and lathered really well. My only complaint was that the lid leaked, but I was okay with that. I bought 2 more this time, and was so disappointed to find that with the rebranding (new look), they had also changed the formula. Different scent (like Dove), thinner, 16oz instead of 18oz for the same price, and the lid still leaks! Lol. Still a good body wash, but I will not be repurchasing. Just not the same, and not for me. :(

We appreciate your support & feedback, Elayna!

Please be assured that while we have updated our labeling, none of our product formulations have been modified in any way.

We always encourage our customers to reach out to us should any issues arise.

If you ever have any questions or concerns, we’re here to assist you!

Great texture

I love the texture of the body butter and how light it is. I don't feel sticky or greasy at all. I did not like the Palmetto Sunset scent so that is the only reason I gave this a 4.

I wanted to like it

This smells good but the texture was dry and gritty. I’m gonna try to melt it and whip it myself.

Thank you for your feedback Gina!

In regards to your body butter product being grainy, we can certainly help with that!

Sometimes the grainy/gritty texture occurs when the butter has melted in a warm/hot atmosphere and has re-solidified in a warm/hot environment as opposed to a cold environment, which when in a cold environment, the natural fatty acids immediately solidify, thus creating a tempered effect that results in a smooth solid butter.

As mentioned on our website, body butters may soften, melt or liquify when introduced to warmer climate temps, which is a normal occurrence for butters in general — Unfortunately, there isn’t a sure fire way to keep butters from melting in warm environments.

However, this is a quick & easy fix!

Simply place your body butter product either in the microwave [in 10 second intervals] or in a bowl of warm/hot water for 1-2 minutes, until completely melted then immediately store it into the refrigerator for 10-20 minutes to create a smooth and solid texture, then you’re good to go!

We do hope that this information has been helpful & should you have any questions or concerns please feel free to contact us.

Milk + Honey Oats

Milk and Honey Oats is officially my go to scent for days when I'm relaxing around the house, and after my nightly shower. My body feels amazing after application, the smell matches the description to the T! I will definitely be ordering again!

Great products

The scrub has a wonderful scent and is a great scrub. Well worth the wait and will definitely reorder. Love all their products!


I like the product but the time that it takes to get the product takes way too long. Unfortunately, I can’t keep using buttermeup because I like my products to arrive timely. 2 weeks is one thing…over a month. Nope.

Thank you for your feedback Eunita!

We’re happy to hear that you’re enjoying our products, please be assured that we do state our order processing times throughout our website, prior to order submission for the convenience and transparency of our customers.

If you ever have any questions or concerns, we’re always here to assist you!

Smells Wonderful

Love it. Smells wonderful all day. Only problem, it’s solid and hard to remove from the jar.

Thank you for your feedback Julie!

We're happy to hear that you're loving your products. If you are having issues with your product(s), please feel free to reach out to us so that we can assist you properly.

Love it!

I love the scent and feel of this body wash!

Vanilla Lavender Body Oil

I'm in heaven. Glides on beautifully & smells divine. Silky smooth for the whole day long.

This is my 3rd or 4th time ordering; it’s that good

This body oil absorbs very well, and the scent is intoxicating. I use it after every shower, and I absolutely love the scent. My boyfriend can’t get enough of the way it smells either. I bought 4 of them this time…

One of my new favorite candles!!

This candle smells divine! It reminds me of a warm and cozy fireplace! The scent lasts hours after the candle is no longer lit.

Glowing skin

It leaves my skin soft and glowing. ❤️

Delicious scent

I love the toasted marshmallow scent but I wish it lingered a little bit longer. I found myself spraying a lot consistently which led to me going through the bottle quickly.

Toasted Marshmallow’s Sexy Older Sister

Cocoa cashmere came and did everything that toasted marshmallow thought she did! In my opinion cocoa cashmere smells similar to toasted marshmallow but the scent is stronger and the throw is amazing!

Body Butter - Earthy + Masculine
Very Disappointed

Butter me up goods has some wonderful scents. However the quality between various orders and their customer service has been less than stellar.

With each order I receive it’s like a guessing game of whether or not it will be accurate. I’ve had items missing, orders shipped to addresses that I didn’t provide them, and more. We won’t even discuss the shipping lead times.

I recently received a gift from a friend who started shopping here at my recommendation. They gave me a butter that I actually already had. When I sniffed it I was SHOCKED to not smell anything….at all. I had her smell the one that owned. Imagine the disappointment of my friend to realize that she didn’t receive what she paid for.

She reached out via email to advise and they basically said tough luck because she didn’t tell them with 3 days of ordering. That is appalling! How was she to know what it was supposed to smell like?! If you’re made aware of an issue with an order, MAKE IT RIGHT! I’ve had many orders where this company has dropped the ball. Each time I reach out to find a resolve and they do nothing. But I draw the line when someone who I encouraged purchase, is also being shortchanged. I can gladly support a company who owns their errors and makes their wrongs right because none of us are perfect and we all need grace. What I can’t support is a company who does not take any ownership of their errors, places blame back on their customers, provides no resolution, and takes a customers money without concern for their satisfaction.

Thank you for your feedback Sabrina!

We’re sorry to hear that you have had a less than stellar experience with us, we certainly do our best to ensure that we assist our customers promptly and in any way possible.

Unfortunately in this case we must honor our company policy as we are unable to offer a replacement or refund for orders that were delivered and received over 60 days ago.

We would have been more than happy to resolve this matter, upon initial delivery, however we did not receive any email inquiries regarding an order issue.

We do apologize for any inconvenience and/or mishaps on our behalf.

We will be sure to note your feedback and concerns, should you have any questions at any time, feel free to contact us!

Kind regards,
Mallory W.

Balancing Serum

This stuff is amazing. I have made it an essential part of my skincare routine because it has my skin feeling fabulous. I bought 2 of these during one of the most recent sales so I don’t run out!


This moisturizer just melts into my skin. I love it.

Yassss for this body butter

The Warm + Decadent one smells amazing and makes me want to bite my own skin, okay?! Buy it. You won't regret it.

Yassss for this body butter

The Warm + Decadent one smells amazing and makes me want to bite my own skin, okay?! Buy it. You won't regret it.

Sweet clean smeel

Also like a vanilla fresh linen smell but it does smell a bit like marshmallows. Its kind of light so I think its better for smaller rooms to make it really stand out. Not in like a living room. I want to try the cocoa Cashmere next